Jay Leno tested the Taycan and here are his thoughts:
Also Car and Driver tested the Taycan vs the Tesla S and concluded that the Tesla is the winner mainly because the Tesla is cheaper to buy:
Judged from the driver’s seat alone, the Taycan is the better car. It meets the high expectations of this storied brand, proves its real-world range, and moves the EV bar on a couple fronts. But price is always a factor; in this case, an insurmountable one.